New Mobile Payment Firms Will Not Displace Banks Easily

Some genuinely believe that banks are in danger of serious displacement by mobile payment and mobile banking competitors. It will be harder than many believe. Banking executives will respond; many already are doing so. 


Beyond that, it is difficult to dislodge "trusted providers" in just about any business you can think of. Observers have been predicting the imminent demise of traditional TV distributors or creators for a decade or more. It has failed to materialize, if the measurement is revenue, rather than viewing hours.


Many veterans of the U.S. competitive local exchange carrier business will agree that upending the leading suppliers in the telecom business has proven to be devilishly hard. Some would argue it has proven difficult for all contenders except the cable companies, at least in the consumer market. 


There arguably has been more success in the business customer segments. 


In the emerging mobile payments and mobile wallet businesses, even players as large as Google and Isis (AT&T, Verizon Wireless and T-Mobile USA) are working with banks, rather than trying to displace them. 


PayPal and Square are more directly threats to banks in the ecosystem, but only to a certain extent. 

Banks will be harder to dislodge than many believe.

Don't be Surprised if Google 1 -Gbps Network Gets Low Buy Rates

There is some uncertainty about the construction time table for Google's 1-Gbps fiber access network being built in Kansas City, Kan. and Kansas City, Mo.


That is a relatively trivial issue, though. The bigger issue is whether any significant number of users actually will buy the service.


With a small handful of exceptions, fiber to home uptake globally seems relatively restrained, suggesting that, for most consumers, what they can buy on the older networks provides a value-price relationship that is good enough. 


Under Google's deal with the Kansas City Board of Public Utilities, the municipal power and water provider that owns the utility poles, the company has the option of attaching fiber either in the space reserved for telecommunications for the standard pole-attachment fee or in the electrical supply space for free (although the latter is costlier because it requires more highly skilled technicians). Kansas City Fiber on Track 



Google and officials in Kansas City, Kan., said Google remains on schedule to go live for the first customers for Google's 1-Gbps network in the first half of 2012.


The Kansas City Star has reported that negotiations over pole attachment rates have slowed the build. Those of you familiar with fixed network construction projects will not be surprised by that report.

Disagreement about rates and conditions for pole attachments are an old, and possibly recurring, issue when new providers want to build new communication networks.

The bigger issue will come when Google actually unveils its prices and products. Some will note that other fiber to home services, in the United States and elsewhere, have not universally been met with high consumer demand.

In Germany, for example, FTTH take rates are just 0.4 percent, though one million homes are able to buy the service. Low take rates

Will Enterprise "Consumerization" Be More than a Device Issue?

Enterprise workers have been bringing their "consumer" tools and apps into the workplace for some time. Enterprises have started to respond by approving use of such devices, such as Apple products in the phone, PC and now tablet areas. 


Longer term, the issue is how much other movement will be seen in the applications area. Skype is among the best current examples of a consumer tool that is widely used within enterprises. So is LinkedIn. Also, Facebook and other social networks now are being adapted for enterprise purposes. 


For the moment, devices seem to be at the forefront, though.

via

Google Fourth Quarter Results Disappoint

Google reported revenues of $10.58 billion for the quarter ended December 31, 2011, an increase of 25 percent compared to the fourth quarter of 2010, and a record for Google.

Though a revenue record, investors were expecting more, primarily on the earnings front, putting pressure on Google's equity price. Google Results

Some think investors are worried about the growing regulatory scrutiny Google is facing, or the implications of its ownership of Motorola Mobility.

But most executives would probably love to have such problems. Consider Google's share of display advertising, which probably will pass Yahoo early in 2012.


Long criticized as being a revenue one trick pony, Google's display ad business now amounts to about 10 percent of total revenues, which continue to be lead by search advertising. 

Remarkably Consistent Smart Phone Video Consumption in France, UK, US Markets

It will come as no surprise to just about anyone that people who own smart phones watch video on those devices. What is interesting, in this bit of survey research, is the consistency of the behavior in different markets. As it turns out, the percentage of respondents to a Yankee Group survey who say they watch video at least once a week on their smart phones is precisely 42 percent each, in France, the United Kingdom and the United States. 


As you also would guess, feature phone users watch far less video. 

AT&T Price Hike Illustrates Trend

Beginning March 1,2012, AT&T's base rate for "measured phone service" in California will rise $3 a month to $15.37 from $12.37, — a 25 percent increase. The charge for additional local calls will be three cents per minute. Separately, AT&T's flat-rate charge for unlimited local calls will increase $1.05, to $21 a month. Some think the rates are not justified. Granted, it's always hard to determine whether retail rates are "fair" or not. But the rates do illustrate one often-forgotten and fundamental change in AT&T's cost structure.

As more and more customers abandon landline service for mobile service or rival providers, a fundamental issue is that a smaller customer base means fixed overhead costs of the network must necessarily be shared by a smaller number of customers. line loss

That means higher costs for the remaining customers, and the process will not stop as customers continue to shift their communications spending to other providers or other types of service.


Capital intensive networks are susceptible to changes in demand. In Denver, where we live in an arid climate and are highly susceptible to drought, residents continually are exhorted to use less water. We have done so. The result is higher rates. Why? Because the water utility's fixed expenses have to be covered, even in the face of lower usage (what we were asked to do), which lowers Denver Water's revenue. 

Predictions about Mobile Web Experiences Will Be Wrong

Union Square Ventures Partner Andy Weissman argues that, up to this point, most observers have assumed that mobile versions of PC experiences would be be similar to the bigger screen experiences, with relatively similar take rates, use cases and business opportunities.

He now suggests that we might have been wrong, and have been applying old rules in a new context, where the predictive value of the older assumptions isn’t as accurate. One might therefore guess that lots of unexpected change will occur as the smart phone experience begins to mature into a very distinct medium.

Reading, social networking, payments, learning, location services, medicine and media are some of the areas where expectations of end user behavior, value and revenue creation could be different than expected.

Think back to Netscape (if you are old enough) when it first was introduced in 1994, or even 1995 and 1996.  What were the then-current experiences Netscape enabled? Keep in mind this was before Amazon, eBay and Google, before e-commerce, before web mail, before Netflix, iTunes.

Who would have predicted then, the way the web has developed? Much the same is likely to happen with mobile web and smart phone-enabled experiences.

Unpredictable mobile impact