"Redemptive Suffering" is Hard to Understand

Good Friday seems an appropriate time to meditate on “redemptive suffering,” something the Catholic Church, perhaps uniquely within the Christian tradition or religion in general, emphasizes.

“Redemptive suffering” is about the ways human suffering can take on spiritual meaning and value, and I have to admit I’ve struggled to understand this for 30 years. 

It isn’t that pain is a “good” thing. Christians are called to alleviate it when they can. But I’ve often wondered what the heck people mean when they say “offer it up to God.”

A long story made short, it means suffering has meaning and purpose. 

Human suffering (unavoidable) can be “offered up” and united with the suffering of Jesus to create spiritual value, for oneself (your suffering is not “meaningless”) or for others (your prayer intentions for others).

“Suffering with” Jesus does not mean you alter what already has been done (“salvation or redemption”) but on the other hand unites you that act.

The way I characterize this is that as cultivating a garden; raising a child; building some useful object; painting; singing or other creative acts are in some sense a participation in genesis (“creation”), so suffering might be viewed (when offered intentionally) as part of the redemption of the universe. 

When someone suffers illness or loss, and intentionally “offers it up,” it becomes a prayer.

People can respond to suffering in different ways, and doing something with it imparts meaning:

• resentment

• despair

• acceptance

• as an offering.

Salvifici Doloris seems to be the most insightful treatment I've found. The idea is that suffering can have meaning and value for you and others, just as any other act of service. Our own suffering, when united purposefully with the suffering that was part of Jesus’ salvific act, is transformed, and helps others.

So suffering is not “meaningless.”  

Catholic teaching is that this happens because of the communion of saints. 

The communion of saints is the spiritual union (in reality, not theoretical) of all Christians, living or dead. We can pray for each other, ask for help and help others, as though all were fully present in the present moment. 

When a person unites their sufferings with Christ's Passion, those sufferings can benefit other souls, spiritually, morally, and redemptively. 

Done that way, suffering has a “creative character”: it produces good. help apply and extend that redemption in time and space to others. 

What I think I learned this year (after 30 of not comprehending) is that the model is suffering endured by Jesus to redeem the universe. That sacrifice transformed suffering into redemption. 

And that is the pattern. Our own personal suffering can be transformed into redemptive reality for others. 

Catholic teaching is that redemptive suffering works in many ways:

• Leading to the conversion of others

• “Speeding” saints entry into heaven

• For some intention (a good for another person)

• To further sanctify the world

• unleashes unselfish love on behalf of those who suffer.

This has nothing to do with what Christ already accomplished (redemption of the world). It has everything to do with how we can wring benefits for other humans out of our own pain. 

So my new understanding, as limited as it might be, is that in Catholic theology, redemptive suffering is quite similar to other Christian practices of charity and mercy. We do things to help others. 

Aspect	Redemptive Suffering	Works of Mercy (Corporal & Spiritual)
Purpose	Helps others spiritually (conversion, purification, graces for souls in need/Purgatory)	Helps others bodily (poor, sick, unhoused) and spiritually (comfort, counsel, prayer)
Union with Christ	Unites personal pain to Christ’s Cross	Serves Christ directly in the suffering neighbor (“You did it to me” – Mt 25:40)
Effect on the doer	Purifies the soul, builds virtue, increases merit	Expresses and grows charity; conforms us to Christ the Servant
Effect on others	Channels invisible graces; supports the Church’s mission	Provides tangible relief + spiritual aid; can open hearts to grace
Biblical root	Colossians 1:24; participation in Passion	Matthew 25 (judgment based on mercy to the needy)
Motive	Love expressed through sacrifice and acceptance	Love expressed through action and compassion

--------------------------

Aspect	Catholic Teaching	Buddhist Teaching
Origin of Suffering	Original sin (Fall of Adam and Eve); disorder introduced into a good creation by free will.	Craving/attachment (tanha), rooted in ignorance of impermanence, no-self, and the three poisons (greed, hatred, delusion).
Nature of Suffering	Physical, emotional, and spiritual pain; part of the fallen human condition but never meaningless.	Dukkha: inherent unsatisfactoriness of all conditioned existence (birth, aging, sickness, death, change).
Purpose / Meaning	Positive redemptive value: unites the sufferer with Christ’s Cross, purifies, atones, builds virtue, and participates in salvation of the world.	None inherent; suffering is a diagnostic fact of existence meant to awaken insight, not to be “offered up” or glorified.
Response to Suffering	Patient endurance, “offer it up,” prayer, sacraments, works of mercy; legitimate to seek relief (medicine, comfort).	Mindful observation without attachment or aversion; cultivate compassion (karuna) and wisdom through meditation and the Eightfold Path.
Path to Overcoming	Faith in Christ, grace received through sacraments, prayer, and charity; hope in the Resurrection.	Noble Eightfold Path: ethical living, meditation, and direct insight into the Three Marks of Existence.
Ultimate Resolution	Eternal life in heaven (Beatific Vision) where suffering is abolished forever; suffering is redeemed, not erased.	Nirvana: complete cessation of craving and rebirth; suffering ends permanently with no remainder.
Role of God / Divine	Personal, loving God who permits suffering but enters it in Christ and brings greater good from it.	No creator God; the universe operates by impersonal laws of karma and dependent origination.