Hal Varian: Data is Cheap, Ubiquitous, So Value Lies in Meaning

More than ten years into the widespread business adoption of the Web, some still fail to grasp the economic implications of cheap, ubiquitous information and communications and modular, open software. But executives are learning fast precisely what the implications are.  

Inside enterprises, ubiquitous information is reshaping and flattening organizational structures. In the broader economy, retailing and distribution processes are transforming. 

The impact is perhaps nowhere more startling than in print media, music and pre-recorded video, where value is so much altered that some distribution channels are being destroyed, others merely reshaped. 

For communications providers the changes are less direct, if no less challenging. Value and revenue now are shifting inexorably towards "data" experiences rather than simple "voice." But data experiences are precisely where loosely-coupled software, hardware and communications change value contributions so much. 

In a broad sense, the global telecom industry is going to have to learn to do what others are being forced to do: assume an environment of cheap, ubiquitous "things" and learn to create value by extracting meaning and usefulness out of those ubiquitous things. 

Global Telecom Dip in 2009 to Reverse in 2010, Climb for 4 Years

Analyst Simon Sherrington says global telecom capex is set to decline by about 0.7 percent in 2009 to around $297 billion, with steeper declines in mature markets such as the United States and Western Europe offset by investments in growth markets such as China and India, and regions such as Africa and the Middle East.

But the contraction should be short-lived. Sherrington forecasts an increase in global spending in 2010 and in the following three years, with the global capex total hitting $350 billion in 2012.

By the Time the Broadband $ is Spent, It Won't be "Stimulus"

For all of the interest companies now are showing in the $7.2 billion broadband access spending that is supposed to happen as part of the "stimulus" package, it is possible the only people who will "get" any incremental money any time soon are lawyers and consultants who claim they can help clients get some of the money.

A large percentage of the money for broadband in the stimulus package won't be spent until 2011 or later, says Jeffrey Eisenach, chairman and managing partner of Empiris, an economic consulting firm. The money, split between the U.S. National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) and the Rural Utilities Service (RUS) of the U.S. Department of Agriculture, will go out in the form of grants, and neither agency is currently set up to allocate billions of dollars, he says.

"In 2014, you're not going to need stimulus in this economy," says Robert Atkinson, president of the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, a tech-focused think tank. "There's a sort of half-life for stimulus spending."

Blockbuster Defies Expectations

The conventional wisdom is that Blockbuster's business model is the equivalent of "toast." In fact, fears of an impending bankruptcy filing caused shares to fall as much as 86 percent early in March, as a result. 

But Blockbuster says domestic same-store sales increased 4.4 percent in the fourth quarter of 2008, representing a 5.3 percent increase when compared to a decline of 0.9 percent in the same period in 2007. 

The increase in same-store sales was comprised of a 2.6 percent decrease in domestic same-store rental comparables and a 36.5 percent increase in domestic same-store retail comparables, which was largely driven by increased sales of games, game merchandise and consumer electronics.

For the full year of 2008, Blockbuster achieved a 6.4 percent increase in domestic same-store sales, compared to a decrease of 6.9 percent in 2007. The 2008 domestic same-store comparables included a 1.2 percent increase in domestic same-store rental comparables and a 37.4 percent increase in domestic same-store retail comparables.

Companies and executives frequently manage to outperform conventional wisdom, and it appears Blockbuster has done so. 

Mobiles are Disruptive to Ad Business

Media and advertising professionals say the pullback of ad dollars and mobile devices becoming personal computers are the most disruptive forces in media today, according to a recent survey by KPMG LLP, the U.S. audit, tax and advisory firm. With media time and spending seen moving away from traditional channels, attention to social media and mobile consumption is expected to increase.

In polling more than 200 media, marketing and advertising executives, KPMG found that 49 percent of respondents indicated that the pullback of advertising dollars is the most disruptive force in media today, followed closely by mobile devices becoming personal computers (40 percent).

The KPMG survey also found that some 75 percent of executives predict that advertisers will move more than a quarter of media time and spending away from traditional channels in the next five years, while social networks and mobile marketing are expected to see increased activity.

While the marketing and branding power of social networking is expected to be increasingly harnessed in the future, 61 percent of executives indicate that fewer than 30 percent of ad agencies have a plan in place to leverage the medium for their clients.

A Humorous Look at Soccer

In my case, something more true of my grandkids than my kids, who preferred football, track and wrestling. Then again, I only have one daughter and three sons, and they managed to get to high school before the soccer craze hit. 

The grandkids have tons of "gold medals" hanging on their bedroom walls, many earned for seasons where no scores were kept and no goalies played. 

Mobile Marketing Evolution: A Prediction

There's one consistent pattern I have noticed for decades in the telecom business, and I'd be willing to bet the same pattern plays out in the mobile marketing business as well. New things start out when pioneers, typically exemplified by new companies, start making a business of the new innovations. 

As the new practices, channels, services and applications start to become mainstream, larger and established players move in and ultimately represent most of the sales volume. We saw that in the mobile business, in digital subscriber line, VoIP, the dial-up Internet access business, content distribution networks and cable TV, for example.

The big exception to this general rule is that a few of the upstarts will so dominate new parts of the ecosystem that they themselves will become the leaders. Google and Amazon come to mind. Still, over the long term, even large assets of this sort might ultimately be absorbed by other contestants in the ecosystem. 

In the mobile advertising business, that means specialists will prove the channel works. Later, though, the full-service agencies will simply incorporate mobile channels within their larger practices. We are quite some way from that sort of consolidation, however. Right now, it's a specialist's game.