About 30 percent of U.S. consumers who purchased Apple’s new iPhone 3G from June through August 2008 switched from other mobile carriers to join AT&T, a new study by NPD Group finds. About 23 percent of consumers, on average, switched carriers between June and August 2008.
By some measures, then, AT&T got a seven-percent share boost from the iPhone.
Nearly half (47 percent) of new AT&T iPhone customers that switched carriers switched from Verizon Wireless, another 24 percent switched from T-Mobile, and 19 percent switched from Sprint.
Before the launch of the iPhone 3G, iPhone sales represented 11 percent of the consumer market for smart phones (January through May 2008); however, after the launch of iPhone 3G, Apple commanded 17 percent of the smartphone market (January through August 2008).
The average price of a subsidized smart phone sold between June and August 2008 was $174, down 26 percent from $236 during the same period last year.
Tuesday, October 7, 2008
iPhone Probably Worth 7 Share Points
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Cox Not Infringing Verizon VoIP Patents, Jury Finds
Verizon Communications has lost its VoIP patent infringement case against Cox Communications Inc, the Wall Street Journal reports. Verizon filed papers in Eastern District Court of Virginia on Jan. 11, 2008 alleging that Cox violated eight patents related to the technology used for completing IP voice calls. The lawsuit came after Verizon had successfully argued that Vonage was infringing its patents.
Verizon included in the lawsuit claims of infringement of four patents Vonage was found to have violated in an earlier case. Verizon was awarded $120 million in damages in that case. But the jury in the Eastern District of Virginia ruled that Cox Communications did not infringe on six Verizon patents.
In addtion to Cox Communications, other leading cable operators perhaps most relieved of all, as it might be hard to defend the notion that any of the leading cable providers were innocent, had Cox been found to be infringing. But other indpendent VoIP providers also have to be breathing a little easier as well.
Had Cox been found to be infringing, it isn't so clear how any other cable company might have escaped litigation, cable or independent VoIP providers alike.
Verizon apparently has recently reached a deal with Comcast in which both companies agreed not to sue each other over patent issues for five years. A Verizon lawsuit against Charter Communications for VoIP patent infringement is still pending.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Netflix Warns of Slowdown
Netflix says its third quarter revenue and earnings per share will fall within prior guidance but that subscriber numbers will fall “just below” the low end of guidance.
“Net subscriber growth in July was in line with expectations but August was unusually weak”, says CFO Barry McCarthy.
There could be lots of reasons for a single-month slowdown. It is possible potential new subscribers were distracted by the Olympics or the Presidential election. But some quickly will jump to the conclusion that economic stringency is pinching Netflix the way some expect a sluggish performance for premium cable channels or perhaps video on demand.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
IP Transit Prices Fall
Median monthly IP transit prices for 1,000 Mbps Gigabit Ethernet (GigE) ports in major U.S. and European cities ranged from $10 to $14 per Mbps in the second quarter of 2008, report researchers at TeleGeography. IP transit prices in Asia remain far higher than in the United States and Europe, which explains the surge in undersea cable construction across the Pacific Ocean.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Monday, October 6, 2008
Long Tail of Social Networking
Nearly half (46%) of those who use social networks have also visited a social network through a mobile phone, according to ABI Research. Of these, nearly 70% have visited MySpace and another 67% had visited Facebook.
No other social networking site reached 15% adoption mobile adoption. That is what one would expect if the Pareto Principle (80/20 rule or "long tail") holds.
"As in the online social networking space, there is clearly a large gap between the big two (MySpace and Facebook) social networks and the others," says research director Michael Wolf. "ABI Research believes this is because consumers do not want to recreate entirely new and separate social networks for mobile, but rather want to tap into their existing social network and have it go with them via the mobile phone. For most, this means MySpace, Facebook, or even both."
The biggest features consumers use when accessing a social network on their phone is checking for comments and messages from their friends, with both of these features registering above 50% for mobile social network users.
Posting status updates also has proven popular, with over 45% of mobile social users letting others what they are up to via their phone.
"The social network is increasingly becoming a central hub for communication across online and mobile domains for many consumers," says Wolf. "To a degree, it allows them to centralize messaging, communication and even digital media consumption through a centralized property on various screens."
That is something enterprise social networks might hope to replicate.
No other social networking site reached 15% adoption mobile adoption. That is what one would expect if the Pareto Principle (80/20 rule or "long tail") holds.
"As in the online social networking space, there is clearly a large gap between the big two (MySpace and Facebook) social networks and the others," says research director Michael Wolf. "ABI Research believes this is because consumers do not want to recreate entirely new and separate social networks for mobile, but rather want to tap into their existing social network and have it go with them via the mobile phone. For most, this means MySpace, Facebook, or even both."
The biggest features consumers use when accessing a social network on their phone is checking for comments and messages from their friends, with both of these features registering above 50% for mobile social network users.
Posting status updates also has proven popular, with over 45% of mobile social users letting others what they are up to via their phone.
"The social network is increasingly becoming a central hub for communication across online and mobile domains for many consumers," says Wolf. "To a degree, it allows them to centralize messaging, communication and even digital media consumption through a centralized property on various screens."
That is something enterprise social networks might hope to replicate.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Apple Has Done It: 10 Million iPhones Sold
Apple has reached its goal of selling 10 million iPhones by the end of the year, says Seeking Alpha writer Andy Zaky.
Estimates for iPhone sales figures for Apple's fourth quarter (calendar quarter three) were called for sales of four million units. It now appears that Apple has sold at least 7 to 7.5 million iPhones in the quarter, nearly 80 percent above consensus.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Friday, October 3, 2008
Watch for Shift to Social and Digital Media
About 65 percent of chief marketing officers surveyed recently by Epsilon say their ad budgets will decrease because of the troubled economy, but more of their money will go toward digital/interactive marketing than before. About 63 percent of the 175 CMOs and marketing execs surveyed report that their spending on interactive and digital marketing has risen, while 59 percent report a decrease in traditional marketing spending.
Those attitudes typically have been important only for media and content providers in the past. These days, those attitudes are important for telcos and mobile providers as well as potentially millions of smaller content providers as well, since blogs and social marketing are at the top of the list of new media CMOs are shifting attention to.
At the same time, 94 percent of those surveyed agreed with the statement, “A tough economic period is precisely the time when marketing plays a key role.”
To offset budget cuts, CMOs are shifting to more targeted and measurable marketing strategies. When asked how their firm determines target market for each channel, 50 percent said they use data-driven marketing techniques: 31 percent stated they use modeling tools to analyze existing customer data (behavioral, preference and demographic) and 19 percent said that they analyze past purchase behavior. In contrast, 28 percent said they made “rough estimates based on past experience.”
CMOs have been early adopters of new media with social computing and blogs receiving the most interest, and instant messaging and interactive TV ads least popular.
Social computing (including word of mouth, social networking sites, viral advertising and so forth.) was the most popular emerging channel with 42 percent of marketing executives expressing interest in adding it to their marketing mix.
Blogs were the second-most-popular emerging channel, with 35 percent of marketers expressing desire to use them and 19 percent already using them.
Almost a third of CMOs mentioned podcasting as an area of interest, with 31 percent interested in adding it to their marketing mix and 18 percent already having done so.
Some 29 percent are interested in Mobile Devices (phones/PDAs) and 22 percent have added them to their marketing mix.
About the survey: The survey was conducted in August 2008. Participants included 175 US CMOs and marketing executives of some of the largest brands in the nation. Some 27% of respondents work at companies with $10 billion or more in annual revenues last year.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Thursday, October 2, 2008
27% of Wireless Users Say They Have Disconnected Landlines
More than one fourth of wireless phone customers have replaced their traditional landline connections at home and are now using wireless service exclusively to communicate on a daily basis, according to J.D. Power and Associates.
The study finds that among the 27 percent of current wireless customers who report replacing their traditional landline phone with wireless service, 61 percent have completely disconnected their home landline service. Additionally, 29 percent of wireless customers ages 18 to 24 report making this switch, compared with only 9 percent of subscribers 65 years or older.
Customers who have used wireless longer are also more likely to switch exclusively to wireless service. In particular, customers who have used wireless service for three years or more report higher landline disconnection levels than those who have used wireless for less than 12 months (19 percent vs. 9 percent, respectively).
“The user experience has steadily improved for wireless customers, and the number of features and applications available for cell phones has increased considerably during the past two years, so it is not unexpected to find that many wireless subscribers are choosing to replace their landline phone entirely with wireless service,” says Kirk Parsons, J.D. Power and Associates senior director. “Wireless service has truly improved to the point where quality and performance are no longer barriers in the decision-making process around switching to exclusive wireless service usage.”
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Wednesday, October 1, 2008
AT&T Creates New Consumer Unit, Featuring "Everything"
AT&T is reorganizing its management, creating separate business units focused on customer segments rather than product lines, further illustrating the seriousness with which AT&T now views creating new kinds of services that transcend networks and devices. Part of the reason for creating a "consumer" services unit is that video, for example, now must be licensed, packaged and delivered across devices (TVs, PCs, mobile devices) and networks (wireless and wired).
The reorganization should make easier the creation of new products that transcend network and device limitations, something AT&T is deadly serious about.
Wireless division CEO Ralph de la Vega now is in charge of all consumer offerings, including wireless, video in all its forms, broadband access and voice. Business services, infrastructure and diversified business are the other three major units.
The reason all of this ultimately will matter for virtually all contestants in the consumer space is that a company the size of AT&T, if successful, can reshape the consumer market and its expectations about what a "service" should be, how it should be packaged, what features such offers "should" feature, how much these features should cost and what payment methods and plans are part of the "new normal."
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Local Loop Not a Natural Monopoly?
Fiber to the customer networks are not a natural monopoly, even though industry participants often think of it in those terms, says Vianney Hennes, permanent representative to European Institutions for Orange France Telecom Group.
So the ideal competitive environment in the age of fiber rollouts should be similar to the way mobile competition now occurs, says Hennes, according to CommsDay reporter Luke Coleman. Presumably that means multiple, facilities-based networks.
It may not mean a call for complete duplication of all physical infrastructure in the local loop. Hennes probably is referring to shared access to ducts and other rights of way, primarily. It seems unlikely an employee of France Telecom would be calling for construction of multiple fully-duplicative local fiber networks by multiple contestants, if only because the economics are prohibitive on the face of it.
Since most recent studies of fiber-to-customer infrastructure suggest a provider must get something on the order of 30 percent penetration of every high-penetration service to make a financial return, and if penetration of video, voice and broadband is assumed to be in the range of 60 to 80 percent of every household, it seems fairly clear that three head-to-head contestants will have a tough time getting to break even. If there are more than three contestants, most of the providers might fail.
He said it was a “self-fulfilling prophecy” when operators say fiber-to-customer upgrades inherently are
monopolistic. “If you think there will be a monopoly somewhere, in the end, you will end up with a
monopoly," he says.
Hennes said that regulatory conditions should be set to allow maximum infrastructure competition,
such as allowing for duct sharing and taking pains to reduce traditional bottlenecks. The industry can move to something that looks like a mobile model, he argues.
How does that work to France Telecom's advantage? If duct sharing and rights of way are widely available, competitors must build their own active fiber networks, while France Telecom does not have to share access to its fiber network, it likely gains some strategic leverage. Not many contestants actually will conclude that building their own networks makes sense, of it if makes sense, it will occur only in some regions and locales, not all.
Oddly enough, opening up more access to rights of way, but requiring contestants to lay their own fiber and active opto-electronics, might create almost as much of an entry barrier as not opening the ducts and rights of way. More openness on the physical layer front seems likely in Europe. But so does mandatory wholesale access to new optical fiber facilities. It is an interesting thought, the local loop not being an actual monopoly.
To some extent, it clearly isn't, as evidenced by the flourishing businesses already run by cable companies and telcos. We know there is room for at least two rival physical networks. What remains unclear is the long-term sustainability of three or more physically-diverse networks. We'll have to watch the overbuilder and municipal networks business to collect more data points. There remain few widescale instances where three broadband networks are widely available to customers.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Tuesday, September 30, 2008
Warning: Zone Alarm Pro Not Compatible with Norton Anti-Virus 2009
Other users--and now me--have discovered that Norton AntiVirus 2009 is incompatible with ZoneAlarm Pro. on a Windows XP (SP3) machine. Try to load Norton AntiVirus and it will crash your operating system, requiring you to do a system restore. You also will find that you must remove the power cord and battery (if on a lap top) to shut the system down, as the incompatibility also prevents you from using the power button to shut down. No matter what you do, the Norton software will lock up the machine if you try to install it.
Apparently these two companies don't like each other very much because it isn't the first time I've had issues with Norton and ZoneAlarm causing me to remove one or both from my machines. It is quite annoying.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
47% of Cable Subs Might Be Willing to Switch

About 47 percent of cable company video subscribers say they are willing to consider switching their video service from cable to an IPTV service, say researchers at CFI Group. That level of interest occurs when customers are presented with a 100-plus channel menu and monthly prices in the $40 to $50 range.
At that level of retail prices, the upside for telcos is not gross revenue nor margin. The upside lies in reducing churn and preserving both unit sales and profit margin for legacy voice and data services. At the moment, bundle customers are about twice as likely to be cable customers as telco customers. One reason for that is the fact that telcos have not had the ability to provide video entertainment services until recently.
If telecom companies are able to provide fiber services to new access areas quickly, and market them effectively, the split of new bundled customers between telecom and cable could widen to 63 percent and 29 percent respectively, CFI argues.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Fluid Cable-Telco Marketing Battles

Nearly 60 percent of surveyed households now have bundled services (telecommunication, internet, and video services), a 13 percent increase since 2007, according to new research by CFI Group. So far, though, cable companies are much more likely to serve bundle buyers, compared to telecom companies. Cable companies subscribe twice as many customers to bundled services as telecoms do, CFI Group says.
And telcos have some work to do: Digital subscriber line services appear to be losing ground, compared to cable modem alternatives. Still, the battleground is fluid: customers increasingly asensitive to rising rates and poor customer service coming from cable providers, CFI suggests.
Some 70 percent of customers cite high rates as one reason for canceling cable TV service, while poor customer service accounts for 40 percent of churn from cable TV service.
Of customers who will switch carriers, 40 percent say that the competition offers better rates and plans.
Customers also seem to be more willing to switch wireless carriers than they were in 2007. Verizon leads all wireless carriers in customer satisfaction and Verizon customers are the least likely to switch carriers. Sprint/Nextel customers are the least satisfied and the most likely to switch.
Nearly 50 percent of households are interested in VoIP and IPTV, but awareness for either has changed little over the past year.
Bundling preferences are likely to change as telcos turn up new video services. Despite cable’s current lead, customers would prefer to bundle communications services with telecommunication companies over cable companies by a two to one margin, CFI Group says. However, 29 percent of customers have no intention of bundling at all, preferring instead to pick and choose the services that best meet their needs.
And though consumers often say "convenience" is why they buy bundles, lower costs probably are the primary driver. The vast majority of customers who choose bundled services make the decision based on price, CFI Group says. Still, 46 percent of customers say they chose a bundled plan because it simplifies billing. Most customers who intend to switch carriers will also choose better pricing and a simplified bill, CFI Group says.
The predicted growth rate for bundling is nine to 17 percent over the next 12 months, slowing slightly over previous years. The greatest opportunity is in meeting the growing market demand for video services provided by telcos. If telecoms are able to provide fiber services to new access areas quickly, and market them effectively, the split of new bundled customers between telecom and cable could widen to 63 percent and 29 percent respectively, reversing the present pattern.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Monday, September 29, 2008
Xohm Launches in Baltimore
Sprint Nextel Corp.has launched its Xohm WiMAX-powered service for mobile customers in Baltimore. Contract-free service options include a $10 day pass, $25 monthly home Internet service and $30 monthly laptop service. Xohm modems cost $60 for a laptop card, an $80 home modem and has average downlink speeds of 2 to 4 megabits per second.
“This is truly an historic day with the birth of a completely new Internet-based business model that alters the dynamics of the traditional telecom industry,” says Barry West, Xohm president.
Xohm hasn't yet achieved that with the launch; it couldn't have done so. It has created a new packaging for mobile access pricing. The day pass, reminiscent of Wi-Fi day pass pricing, is helpful. The $30 card or dongle pricing does undercut rival pricing from other providers. Prices for tethered service are roughly in line with what Clearwire already was offering.
So far, though, Xohm does not appear to differ much from fixed broadband service, save for the pricing level. Where it clearly hopes to pose a challenge is to contract-based voice service, but Clearwire isn't promising it is going to make that its battleground. Right now, it mostly looks like a less-expensive, contract-free version of 3G mobility service, with better throughput.
That's not a bad thing by any means. Still, Xohm's rhetoric is ahead of its vision, at the the moment. There are lots of reasons. One business model Xohm really wants to create is a simple, low-cost, casual use model beyond the day pass. That will require the ability to discover and authenticate new devices registering to the network. That means creating means to deal with MAC addresses and IP addresses not already registered in its authentication servers as a "current customer."
Supporting the typical user input operations on smaller devices other than PCs is an issue, but probably not so much as the authentication of new MAC and IP addresses whose users want to register for some relatively-casual use of the Xohm network. That means processes for
discovery, certification, and management of new devices on the WiMax network, when network usage might be quite episodic. Right now it probably just means supporting WiMAX modems, whatever the form factor.
What Xohm really wants is the ability to authenticate and provide service to MP3 players, electronic book readers and other devices mobile networks have not had to deal with in the past. We might be a year away from that.
And that's when Xohm will start to fulfill its promise.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
People Now Text More than Talk

The typical U.S. mobile subscriber sends and receives more SMS text messages than telephone calls, according to new research conducted byNielsen Mobile.
During the second quarter of 2008, a typical U.S. mobile subscriber placed or received 204 phone calls each month. In comparison, the average mobile customer sent or received 357 text messages per month, a 450 percent increase over the number of text messages circulated monthly during the same period in 2006.
U.S. teens (ages 13 to 17) had the highest levels of text messaging in the second quarter 2008, sending and receiving an average of 1,742 text messages per month. In comparison, teens took part in an average of 231 mobile phone calls per month, during the same time period.
Gary Kim was cited as a global "Power Mobile Influencer" by Forbes, ranked second in the world for coverage of the mobile business, and as a "top 10" telecom analyst. He is a member of Mensa, the international organization for people with IQs in the top two percent.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)
Yes, Follow the Data. Even if it Does Not Fit Your Agenda
When people argue we need to “follow the science” that should be true in all cases, not only in cases where the data fits one’s political pr...
-
We have all repeatedly seen comparisons of equity value of hyperscale app providers compared to the value of connectivity providers, which s...
-
It really is surprising how often a Pareto distribution--the “80/20 rule--appears in business life, or in life, generally. Basically, the...
-
One recurring issue with forecasts of multi-access edge computing is that it is easier to make predictions about cost than revenue and infra...