Monday, November 8, 2021

How Much Room for Indpendent ISPs in U.S. Markets?

A key issue for potential internet service providers operating as  overbuilders is market share. When competing against two incumbent ISPs, and picking markets, what is a reasonable expectation for market share, and eventually installed base? 


Tucows, which operates Ting Internet, has been getting adoption of about 31 percent where it chooses to build its symmetrical fiber-to-home networks. 


Generally speaking, both AT&T and Verizon, where they offer fiber-to-home service, have been getting installed base a bit higher than 40 percent, in markets where they have been marketing for at least a few years. AT&T is hopeful it can, over time, boost share to about 50 percent of the market. 


Unless cable operators fail to respond, and that is highly unlikely, their installed base could  drop from about 70 percent to perhaps 50 percent if telcos adopt FTTH on a wide scale. That obviously leaves little room for third providers at scale, on a sustainable basis. 


To be sure, Ting Internet is “cherry picking” its markets, picking locations where it believes it has the best chance to gain share. 


Those typically are higher-income suburban areas where the main competitor, in terms of speed, is the cable operator, and where a telco remains wedded to copper access. Market share should be lower in areas where both the incumbent cable operator and telco offer gigabit speeds. 


In those markets, assuming pricing is relatively comparable, Ting’s advantage in part will rely on upstream bandwidth capabilities, at least where compared to the cable operator. 


It is harder to predict what might be the case in a decade, when telcos and cable operators alike might be offering access routinely in the gigabit to multi-gigabit ranges, possibly with upstream bandwidth high enough that return bandwidth is not an issue for nearly all customers, even if not fully symmetrical. 


To be sure, terms and conditions and general customer expectations about experience will matter. Internet service providers as a class do not score highly in the American Customer Satisfaction Index, for example. Whether specialist providers can do better, on a sustainable basis, is the issue.  


No comments:

Generative AI Will NOT have the Impact Many Expect

Generative artificial intelligence, to say nothing of machine learning or neural networks (and eventually general AI), might collectively re...