Tuesday, May 21, 2024

Has AppleTV+ "Failed?"

Some might argue that Apple TV has “failed,” in the sense of not being a leading video streaming provider in terms of market share. 


But companies in the same industry often have very-different business models, and often, some revenue-producing segments of those businesses exist in large part to support the core revenue model. 


Apple TV, for example, arguably exists to support Apple’s core hardware sales model. Microsoft’s videogame business arguably is used to support the firm’s hardware sales. Amazon’s streaming video service is a way of driving subscriptions for Amazon Prime e-commerce services. 


Also, some might argue that streaming also contributes to the “services” revenue streams that most believe are the key to Apple’s future growth. 


Business Model


Core Revenue Model

Supporting Products/Services

Examples


Hardware Sales

Selling physical IT equipment

Personal computers (desktops, laptops) - Servers and storage  Networking equipment (routers, switches) - Mobile devices (smartphones, tablets)

Dell Technologies (DELL) - HP Inc. (HPQ)  Apple (AAPL)

Software Licensing

Selling licenses to use software applications

Perpetual licenses (onetime purchase) - Subscription licenses (monthly/yearly fees)  Open-source software with paid support plans

Microsoft (MSFT) - Adobe (ADBE)  Red Hat (RHT)

Software as a Service (SaaS)

Subscription-based access to cloud-hosted software

Web-based applications (CRM, project management, email) - Scalable and flexible deployment options - Integration with other cloud services

Salesforce (CRM) - Zoom Video (ZM) - Dropbox (DBX)

Platform as a Service (PaaS)

Providing a platform for building and deploying applications

Development tools and frameworks - Infrastructure and services (compute, storage, databases) - Integration with other cloud services

Amazon Web Services (AWS) - Microsoft Azure (MSFT) - Google Cloud Platform (GOOG)

Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS)

Renting out virtualized computing resources

Servers, storage, networking - Scalable on-demand resources - Pay-as-you-go pricing model

Amazon Web Services (AWS) - Microsoft Azure (MSFT) - Google Cloud Platform (GOOG)

Managed Services

Providing ongoing management and support for IT infrastructure

System administration - Network monitoring and security - Cloud management services - Help desk support


IBM (IBM) - Accenture (ACN) - DXC Technology (DXC)

Value-Added Reseller (VAR)

Reselling hardware and software with additional services

Integration and customization services - Training and implementation support - Ongoing maintenance and support

Insight Enterprises (NSIT) - SHI International Corp.

Freemium

Offering a basic version for free with premium features for a fee

Freemium software applications - Mobile apps with in-app purchases - Subscription upgrades


Spotify (SPOT) - Evernote (EVER) - LinkedIn (MSFT)

Advertising-Based

Generating revenue through advertising displayed to users

Free online content (news, videos, social media) - Targeted advertising based on user data - Freemium model with ad-supported basic tier

Meta Platforms (META) - Alphabet (GOOG) (YouTube) - The New York Times Company (NYT)


Some might see Apple TV as a failure, within the “video streaming service” category. But as with Amazon Prime Video, success in that category is not really the point. Support for the core business model is the point.


Apple has had appliances that failed commercially, the point being that product failures can occur for products or applications. So can successes that support the core business model, such as the App Store supporting iPhone sales.


Device Name

Year Released

Reasons for Failure

Apple III

1980

High price point - Buggy operating system - Hardware problems

Apple Lisa

1983

Extremely high price point - Limited software library for a business-oriented machine

Macintosh Portable

1989

Bulky and heavy design - Short battery life - High price tag

Newton MessagePad

1993

Inaccurate and frustrating handwriting recognition - High price for limited functionality

Power Macintosh G4 Cube

2000

Unique but impractical rounded cube design - Limited upgradeability - High cost

eMac

2002

Confusing branding (targeted towards education but lacked features for mainstream users) - Limited software compatibility

iPod Hi-Fi

2006

Niche market - High price compared to portable MP3 players with speaker docks

AirPower

(Canceled in 2019)

Technical challenges in creating a wireless charging mat for multiple devices simultaneously

HomePod (Original)

2018

High price compared to competitors - Limited features for the price - Siri voice assistant not as advanced as competitors



No comments:

DIY and Licensed GenAI Patterns Will Continue

As always with software, firms are going to opt for a mix of "do it yourself" owned technology and licensed third party offerings....