Friday, November 28, 2025

Coopitition is a Pretty Old Story in Technology

“Coopitition” happens frequently in many markets, as competitors find they also cooperate with their rivals. But value chain participants also often move into other parts of the chain, meaning customers become competitors. 


Original Supplier

Customer (Later Competitor)

What the Customer Originally Bought

How/When Customer Became Competitor

Nature of Competition

Intel

Apple (M1/M2/M3 chips)

x86 CPUs for Mac computers

2020: Apple launched Apple Silicon and began replacing Intel CPUs in all Macs

Direct chip-level competitor; vertically integrated into SoC design

Qualcomm

Samsung, Huawei (HiSilicon), Apple (modems underway)

Mobile baseband chips

Samsung & Huawei developed in-house modems; Apple pursuing own modems

Reduced reliance on Qualcomm; internal components compete directly

NVIDIA

Amazon AWS, Google, Microsoft Azure

GPUs for cloud AI workloads

Clouds built custom AI chips (AWS Trainium/Inferentia, Google TPU, Microsoft MAIA/Cobalt)

Cloud providers become GPU substitutes and new chip vendors

Cisco

Amazon AWS (cloud networking), Arista, large enterprises with internal networks

Networking gear for data centers

Hyperscalers built their own switches and disaggregated network OS

Displaces traditional Cisco purchases with in-house designs

Oracle, Microsoft

Salesforce, Workday, ServiceNow

Databases and infrastructure for enterprise apps

SaaS firms built full-stack platforms competing with traditional enterprise software

Customers became full software suite competitors

Google Maps API

Uber, Lyft

Location services, navigation APIs

Ride-hailing firms built proprietary mapping to reduce dependence

Competes with mapping providers and reduces reliance on Google

Android/Google

Samsung (Tizen), Huawei (HarmonyOS)

Android mobile OS

Developed alternative smartphone OS platforms

Competing mobile ecosystems reducing Android dependency

AWS Marketplace vendors

AWS (Basics, managed services)

AWS acted as infrastructure + reseller of partner products

AWS launched services competing directly with partners (e.g., ElasticSearch/Opensearch, Datadog-like monitoring)

High-profile “customer-turned-competitor” ecosystem conflict

IBM, Dell, HP infrastructure

Major banks, retailers, healthcare systems

Enterprise servers, storage, and IT services

Internal cloud teams built private clouds replacing vendor systems

Vertical integration into infrastructure previously purchased

Facebook/Meta (mobile platforms reliance)

Meta’s VR/AR device program (Quest)

Reliance on Apple/Google mobile platforms

Meta developed its own hardware/software ecosystem

Competes with platform providers to escape dependency

Telcos buying vendor gear

AT&T, Verizon, Deutsche Telekom (open RAN initiatives)

Proprietary RAN equipment from Nokia/Ericsson

Built open-source or disaggregated RAN alternatives

Reduces dependence on traditional equipment vendors

IBM/Intel server vendors

Google, Amazon, Facebook data-center hardware

Commodity servers

Hyperscalers designed their own servers and power systems

Competing designs via OCP and private supply chain


That also can be seen in the market for neural processing units, where former customers Google and Amazon now have emerged as important suppliers of NPUs used in place of graphics processor units, even if many of the use cases are internal to those firms. 


Companies such as Google (Tensor Processing Units) and Amazon (Inferentia/Trainium chips) primarily use their NPUs internally or sell access through their cloud services, obscuring any direct "retail" market share comparison.


NPU Segment / Use Case

Dominant Architecture / Product Type

Market Share Context & Key Vendors

Key Vendor Dominance / Market Share Notes

Data Center / Cloud AI (Training,  Inference)

GPU (for Training,  General-Purpose AI),  ASIC/Custom NPUs (for specific Inference)

This segment includes hyperscalers using hardware internally (like Google's TPUs) or for cloud-based services.

NVIDIA holds a dominant share (often cited as 90%+ for high-end AI training accelerators/GPUs, which are often grouped with NPUs). Google (TPU), Amazon (Trainium/Inferentia), and AMD (Instinct) are the primary competitors in the custom/dedicated space.

Edge Devices (Retail/B2C)

Integrated NPUs (AI-SoCs) and Dedicated Edge NPUs

This segment covers chips embedded in consumer products for on-device AI (smartphones, PCs, smart home, automotive).

Qualcomm (Snapdragon), Apple (A/M series chips), and Samsung (Exynos) dominate the smartphone/tablet space, which accounts for the largest application share (e.g., 37.6% of the total NPU market application in 2024). Intel (Core Ultra) is a major player in the PC NPU market.

Edge Market Share (Application)

Smartphones & Tablets

The largest single application area, driving the growth of retail NPU units.

Estimated 35% - 40% of the NPU market application share is in retail, for smartphones and tablets.

Data Center NPU Share (Product Type)

Data Center NPUs

Market share based on the volume of processing units deployed in large-scale data centers.

Data Center NPUs maintained an estimated 51.6% of the neural processor market share in 2024, and much of that represents internal consumption by Amazon and Google. 


Google designs and uses TPUs for its own services including search, translate, Gemini AI, for example. But Google does make its TPUs available to Google Cloud Platform customers as a service, though it does not sell the chips.


No comments:

On the Use and Misuse of Principles, Theorems and Concepts

When financial commentators compile lists of "potential black swans," they misunderstand the concept. As explained by Taleb Nasim ...