Showing posts with label municipal Wi-Fi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label municipal Wi-Fi. Show all posts

Saturday, March 1, 2008

Covad Dips Toe into Metro Wi-Fi

Covad Communications is trying a different approach to metro Wi-Fi services, targeting services at businesses rather than consumers to create a revenue base.

Covad will build a Wi-Fi test network in a square-mile business district in San Carlos, Calif., using an approach far more narrow than what a regional nonprofit and a consortium including Cisco Systems and IBM had once envisioned. Covad also will limit its downside by agreeing to operate the network for a period of three months.

An earlier proposal by the Silicon Valley Network and Silicon Valley Metro Connect didn't take off, and revenue was the chief culprit. Azulstar, the startup that was to build and operate the network, couldn't get funding for two test networks at about $500,000 each.

That was supposed to be the start of a project serving 1,500 square miles and about 40 cities.

Technology really isn't the issue. Covad wants to find out whether it can get enough small business users to anchor a larger or more permanent effort.

Covad’s wireless business unit already serves business customers in San Carlos, allowing Covad to overlay the Wi-Fi capability on top of its fixed wireless broadband service. Central to the test is discovery of whether a repeatable financial and operational model exists.

Following the completion of the test, Covad Wireless will explore expanding the mesh service to additional locations in the region.

Covad Wireless operates California’s largest fixed broadband wireless network serving businesses, and the company views the trial as a way to test a theory: that it can reach incremental new customers in the very-small and home office segments it so far has not focused on.

Up to this point, Covad Wireless has focused on business customers requiring a T1 or higher bandwidth. So the issue is whether a sustainable business case exists for users who may not need, or are not willing to pay for, nailed up T1 connections.

Sunday, January 20, 2008

Free Muni Wi-Fi in Colorado Town: But It's Bad News

Residents of Longmont, Colo. temporary have free access to the municipal Wi-Fi network operated there by Gobility. Access is free because Gobility lost its billing contract and literally can't bill for access. It's bad news because the network is for sale, Gobility apparently finding it cannot raise additional funds to keep the network in operation.

Kite Networks, owned by Texas-based Gobility, provides wireless broadband service in Longmont and to approximately 17,000 customers across 21 markets.That works out to about 809 customers per market. So it is probably no surprise that Gobility is finding the business a really tough proposition.

Longmont’s city council is taking a look at whether the city itself could buy and run the network. But Longmont has Digital Subscriber Line service available from Qwest starting at about $20 a month and Comcast offers cable modem service for about $40 as a stand-alone service. There are no particular signal coverage limitations that prevent use of wireless broadband from the major national suppliers and perhaps a dozen third party ISPs offer DSL service as well. It just isn't clear that a municipal Wi-Fi network is needed or that paying customers exist in sufficient numbers to sustain a business, even if operated by the city.

A vote of Longmont residents would be required before Longmont could consider a bid.

Sunday, November 4, 2007

Silicon Valley Wi-Fi Hits Wall

Silicon Valley has been working for nearly two years to roll out an ambitious Wi-Fi plan covering the entire area. The project continues to face delays, though, among them investment. So far, investors aren’t willing to foot the $500,000 bill for pilot testing. Muni Wi-Fi is facing problems everywhere.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

EarthLink San Francisco Network Now Toast


EarthLink will not be providing free wireless Internet access throughout San Francisco. As promised, EarthLink is not proceeding with any new muncipal Wi-Fi networks when it has to pay the full cost of construction, as would have been the case in San Francisco.

Under the original deal, EarthLink would have invested $14 million to $17 million to build the network. EarthLink also expected to be able to charge $22 a month for a premium tier of service.

San Francisco officials probably will issue another proposal request. And EarthLink conceivably could get additional sponsors. But it's getting tough to make the numbers work when tethered broadband rates now are so affordable. In cities where muni Wi-Fi networks are in operation, or have been proposed, it isn't unusual to find tiers of service comparable to Wi-Fi available for $10 to $15 a month.

Also, as video becomes a more important part of the Internet experience, muni Wi-Fi networks just aren't going to be able to keep up.

No Bidders Left for Chicago Wi-Fi


Chicago has failed to reach agreement with either at&t or EarthLink, each of which had proposed building a municipal Wi-Fi network for the city. Just a few years ago, backers were arguing a business case could be made for either ad-supported free service or for-fee service at rates of $20 a month. But that was before U.S. telephone companies got serious about broadband pricing and dropped access costs behow $20 for service very comparable to what muni Wi-Fi networks were supposed to offer.

at&t charges $20 a month for speeds of 1.5 megabits a second in Chicago and will provide connections half that fast for $10 to new subscribers. In other cities such as Houston, an 800 kbps connection can be purchased for about $15 a month.

In Lompoc, Calif., the city signed up fewer than 500 users out of a population of more than 40,000.

So it looks like we are nearing the end of the muni Wi-Fi craze. Though some networks, primarily for public safety and municipal operations, might still be viable, it doesn't appear that most municipal Wi-Fi networks will prove commercially viable outside high-density urban cores.

And even there, how hard is it to find a T-Mobile hotspot at a Starbucks?

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

EarthLink Pays Houston Fine; Might Be Off the Hook


EarthLink is paying the city of Houston a $5 million penalty fee for missing its first deadline in building the city's municipal Wi-Fi network. The payment might ultimately let EarthLink off the hook for the entire network build, though technically the payment buys about nine months to begin construction. The contract calls for complete construction time of two years.

Of course, EarthLink already has said it is no longer interested in continuing under the original contract terms, so unless the contract is renegotiated in some way, the network won't be built, at least not by EarthLink. It might not be the last fine EarthLink pays.

The city of Houston is also free to take proposals from other vendors during the nine-month period, and could award the contract to another company, observers say.

Considering that at&t offers Houston residents a $15 Digital Subscriber Line service running at 768 kilobits a second, it's hard to see how much share EarthLink might get for a service that will wholesale to retailers at $12 a month for a 1 Mbps service. The retail price then likely will have to be set at $15 or more.

"Tokens" are the New "FLOPS," "MIPS" or "Gbps"

Modern computing has some virtually-universal reference metrics. For Gemini 1.5 and other large language models, tokens are a basic measure...