Tuesday, November 17, 2026

To Fix a Problem, it Must First be Recognized

Public satisfaction with the performance of public schools has hit a new low, according to Gallup, and negative views have accelerated since about 2020. In fact, parents are dissatisfied at a 2:1 ratio over those who are satisfied. And test score performance has significantly worsened since the Covid pandemic. 


source: Gallup 


The biggest decline in satisfaction comes from parents who identify as Democrats, though a steep falloff in satisfaction has happened with those who identify as Republicans or independents. 


source: Gallup


Perhaps shockingly, schools are rated worst at producing humans who can think critically, though on no outcomes were public schools seen as performing well. That poor perception of critical thinking will be much more important as artificial intelligence starts to automate routine cognitive operations. 


And it probably has to be said that the current emphasis on what might be called indoctrination in the schools absolutely does not help. 


Though some will find it contentious, there is a plausible correlation between low critical thinking skills of students n U.S. public schools, as shown by a recent Gallup survey; low test scores on standardized tests  and social concerns in U.S. public education, such as promotion without demonstration of competence; "woke"  ideas in the curriculum and the impact on "cancel culture" that necessarily rules out critical thinking. 


When some ideas outside the approved orthodoxy are not allowed expression, fuller critical thinking skills acquisition can well be stifled. 


The recent Gallup data, long-term achievement trends, practices like social promotion and cultural dynamics around contested ideas in schools and broader society point in related directions. 


Critical thinking requires evaluating evidence, considering alternatives, tolerating cognitive dissonance, and revising beliefs. Those habits are undermined by weak skills foundations, low accountability for competence, and environments that treat certain conclusions as off-limits.


source: Gallup


Standardized test score performance shows some of the problems, as a 2024 assessment by The Nations Report Card shows. Students are graduating with clear skills deficiencies.  


Assessment

Finding

Significance

Grade 4 reading

31% at or above NAEP Proficient

Most students did not reach this benchmark

Grade 8 reading

29% at or above Proficient

Significant weakness in reading comprehension

Grade 8 mathematics

28% at or above Proficient

Less than one-third reached the benchmark

Grade 8 science

31% at or above Proficient

38% scored below NAEP Basic

Grade 12 mathematics

45% below NAEP Basic

Serious deficiencies among students approaching graduation

Grade 12 reading

32% below NAEP Basic

The largest such percentage in the assessment's history


Pretending our system is working does not help.


No comments:

To Fix a Problem, it Must First be Recognized

Public satisfaction with the performance of public schools has hit a new low, according to Gallup, and negative views have accelerated sinc...