Manufacturing Might be Growing Where We Do Not Expect

Manufacturing employment in the United States has surpassed its pre-Covid pandemic levels, the first time since the 1970s that the sector has regained all the jobs it lost in a recession. But the places where growth is happening have changed.

The manufacturing recovery has not reached the “Rust Belt” states of Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Michigan, and Wisconsin. But states in the Sun Belt and Mountain West, such as Florida, Texas, and Utah, are well above pre-pandemic manufacturing employment.

The post-pandemic period also shifted manufacturing growth away from rural areas and towards small urban counties, which have become the sector’s primary drivers of job creation.

Before COVID 19, large urban and suburban counties enjoyed the fastest manufacturing jobs growth.  Since 2019, small urban counties have become dominant in manufacturing job creation. 

These areas, which previously accounted for less than 20 percent of new manufacturing jobs in the four years before the pandemic, have accounted for 61 percent of all manufacturing jobs added from 2019 to 2023, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data. 

source: Economic Innovation Group

And what seems clear is that although most manufacturing industries have recovered from their pandemic job losses, computer and electronics manufacturing and chemical manufacturing are growing faster than before the pandemic.

The new jobs increasingly feature higher-skill roles, have grown most in small urban counties and seem to feature more contingent labor (contractors rather than employees). 

Change	Pre-Covid	Post-Covid
Automation/Digitalization	Gradual, uneven	Rapid, industry-wide
Workforce skill requirements	More low-skill jobs	Shift to high-skill roles
Supply chain strategy	Cost-driven, global	Resiliency, domestic focus
Growth Patterns	Rural & urban	Mostly small urban counties
Job Structure	More permanent	More temp/contract work
Government/Private Investment	Limited	Massive new investment

For economic development advocates, perhaps a takeaway is the growing importance of electronics and computer manufacturing, which seems to be growing faster and perhaps in locations one might not expect, especially smaller urban areas.