One reason dissatisfaction with the public schools is so high is the negative correlation between spending and outcomes. Real per-pupil spending has risen sharply while scores have been flat or worse.
In 1997 dollars, real spending per pupil rose from $3,645 in 1970 to $6,434 in 1995, according to one study. Real spending was up about 84 percent by 1990, over 100 percent by 2000, and almost 150 percent by 2010.
More recently, the national average rose about 21 percent in real terms, from $13,043 in 2002 to $16,526 in 2023. Schools had 22 percent more inflation-adjusted money in 2023 to 2024 than a decade earlier.
On the other hand, reading scores are about where they were in the early 1990s, while math is higher than in the 1990s but well below its 2013 peak. In 2024, just 35 percent of 12th graders were proficient in reading, the lowest since 1992, according to the National Assessment Governing Board.
Studies by the National Assessment of Educational Progress were disheartening.

source: Natiional Assessment of Educational Progress
Worse, one might argue, increased spending has correlated with worse outcomes for reading and math skills.
Catholic schools, meanwhile, seem to achieve higher test scores on lower per-pupil spending; higher graduation rates and college admissions. To be sure, there are possible “selection” effects. Catholic parents are required to be more involved with the schools, share common religious values, while Catholic schools arguably spend less on non-educational items than many public schools seem to do.
Still, the negative correlation between spending and outcomes is further upheld. Perhaps it is not true that money “doesn’t matter.” It does. But higher spending does not achieve outcomes, either.
At some point, we have to acknowledge that some set of inputs and practices other than “more money” have to change, if we want better outcomes.
No comments:
Post a Comment