Mobile is Not "Too Big to Fail"

Some people set up straw men that are easy to knock down, such as the big, rich telcos and mobile providers. Reality is more complex. They still are big, but they also are businesses facing cannibalization of their core revenue stream, voice, and will have to replace most of that revenue with something else.

We as a nation have made this sort of mistake before, trying to bring more competition to the landline voice business precisely as that business was entering a serious period of decline. Mobile providers now are in the same predicament. No matter how big they are, their base business is going to go away, for the the most part, meaning every single cent of revenue they now earn will have to be replaced.

If you think the telecom business is in great shape you don't work in the business. Granted U.S. wireless data revenues grew five percent quarter over quarter in the third quarter of 2009 and 27 percent year over year, to reach $11.3 billion by the end of the third quarter of 2009, according to analyst Chetan Sharma.

But overall service provider average revenue per user decreased by 14 cents during the third quarter. Average voice ARPU declined by 57 cents per user while the average data ARPU grew by 43 cents.

The point is simply that the communications business already is in the midst of a necessary transition from its traditional revenue models to new models, none of which are assured. It is going to take a great deal of very-hard work to pull this off and while consumer displeasure with such providers is understandable at times, they are not "too big to fail."

Most of that gain in data revenue was realized by Verizon and AT&T, which between them accounted for 80 percent of the increase in data revenues in the third quarter. AT&T and Verizon also now account for 68 percent of the market data services revenues and 61.5 percent of the subscriber base, Sharma says.

AT&T experienced the most growth with a six-percent increase quarter over quarter,  followed by Verizon and Sprint with five percent revenue growth each.

Overall mobile service provider revenue grew about two percent year over year. On an annualized basis, data represents about 28 percent of total mobile service provider revenues.

Analyst Chetan Sharma estimates that by end of 2009, U.S. mobile data traffic is likely to exceed 400 petabytes, up 193 percent from 2008.

Smartphones also now represent 25 percent of U.S. devices in service, says Sharma, while mobile penetration stands at about 91 percent.

The average number of text messages used in the U.S. market now averages almost 568 messages per subscriber per month.