Saturday, April 18, 2020

Will Conventional Wisdom About Pandemic Winners Prove Wrong?

Conventional wisdom about the financial impact of Covid-19 stay-at-home policies is that they will devastate small businesses and the self-employed, throw most economies into recession and slam firm earnings for a couple quarters to a couple of years. 

The conventional wisdom also suggests connectivity providers might see a bit of revenue deceleration from firms that go out of business and lower levels of business activity, though possibly balanced by some slight uptake of consumer spending for internet access and streaming video services. Most consumer apps arguably are getting much more use as well. 

Almost everyone would expect revenue lift for suppliers of videoconferencing services, though the long-term impact is harder to predict. 

Conventional wisdom might prove to be wrong, though, especially when temporary behavior is extrapolated into the future in a linear way, to suggest a big permanent change in business and consumer behavior. Underlying and pre-existing trends of all types are likely to get a boost, to be sure. 

But the amount of permanent and on-going change is almost certainly going to disappoint. 

The “problem” with many internet services and apps is that usage does not change in linear fashion with usage, as consumption of voice services once did. A dramatic increase in home internet access usage does not necessarily lead to increased usage charges. So perhaps costs are up marginally, but revenue does not change. 

You might assume newly-popular videoconferencing services such as Zoom would be seeing instant lift in revenue (at least at the margin) as usage explodes. But that would be true only if substantial numbers of new accounts and users are of the for fee type, and that seems quite unclear at the moment.

Every ad-supported consumer app faces cutbacks in advertising. Surely streaming services will be winners, one might think. In a narrow sense, yes. But the owners of many streaming services have other huge revenue components with zero revenue (theme parks, theatrical release of new movies, merchandise sales, cruise operations and so forth). Overall firm revenue will fall, even if some lift in streaming revenue might occur.

There arguably was some initial lift in sales of PCs as people faced the reality of more time and demand on their computing devices. But that is balanced by almost-certain reductions in business spending on all manner of information technology, as projected revenue falls. 

Mobile phone sales are likely to fall, as retail stores have been closed. Cloud computing suppliers will win, as increased usage means more demand for computing and storage services, at least temporarily. But there could be issues unrelated to the increase in cloud computing demand. 

Amazon is selling more, to be sure. But it also is shipping more, which means higher costs. That does not directly affect Amazon Web Services revenue, but does mean total firm results are going to be influenced by other parts of the business. 

Microsoft does not face e-commerce shipping cost impact, but will see lower hardware and possibly software revenues, but if those revenues are reported in a category that also includes servers and server software, the total impact is unclear, with both revenue increases and decreases. 

The point is that usage does not equal revenue in any linear way. Nor can be extrapolate from present trends in a linear way. The touted “new normal” might, in five years, simply be the “old normal” with a temporary spike or dip in underlying trends. 

If you look at remote work trends over a 40-year period or so, growth has been slow and steady, despite periods of boom and bust. No “new normal” has emerged. Of course, one always can argue that the inflection point simply has not been reached, and it will in the wake of the pandemic. 

But 40 years is a long time to wait for an inflection point. Looking at many other services with that lifespan, one might more fruitfully argue that if an inflection has not happened yet, it may never happen.

No comments:

Many Winners and Losers from Generative AI

Perhaps there is no contradiction between low historical total factor annual productivity gains and high expected generative artificial inte...