Can a Tablet Replace a Smartphone?

Most people rationally consider a tablet a replacement for a PC of some sort, typically a notebook or netbook. But it has been noted in some cases that some users might consider a tablet a replacement for a smart phone. As odd as that might sound, consider a case where a traveling worker carriers two mobiles and a notebook, and possible a Kindle and iPod as well. That's a lot of screens.

The typical user probably would choose the smart phone for the "go everywhere" device, it is safe to say. And it would take a special set of circumstances to create conditions where that assumption could be challenged. A five-inch tablet with full voice and text messaging support is the perhaps-obvious example. So far, such a device does not exist. But five-inch tablets are available. read more here

But some do suggest that carrying a tablet everywhere is a real option. read more here, for example. It isn't the most-logical combination of devices, but consider a situation where user carries a simple feature phone for voice and text, and no smartphone, using the tablet as the connected Internet device.

The not hard to understand scenario is smartphone plus tablet, though. So far, there does not seem to be much evidence that the tablet generally is a replacement for anything but a notebook or netbook. Still, there are lots of substitutions some users will find reasonable.

Lots of business users carry mobile broadband dongles. A smartphone can in many cases displace the dongle. A traveling user might then find that the amount of time the smartphone is used as a Wi-Fi hotspot vastly outstrips the amount of time the device is used as a phone. Still, the advantage of the smartphone is its versatility, functioning as the voice and texting platform, GPS device when out of town and the personal Wi-Fi hotspot. Whether the second device is a tablet or notebook depends on the type of work the traveling worker does.

Content consumers who just need web access and email can easily do with a tablet. Content creators will find a notebook a better choice. So far, at least, the tablet does not seem to be a substitute for a smartphone.